Huge disappointment!
Added 1/30/2010
I bought this DVD after reading the book and anxiously waited for it to arrive. I guess great anticipation leads to great disappointment because this is one of the worst movies I have seen in a long time. I even watched it again just to be fair thinking maybe I had had a bad night. No, it was even worse the second time.
Let me say that I was incredibly moved by the book. It made the human experience of WWII real to me in a way that no History Channel documentary ever could. I felt I knew the characters and was moved to tears by their stories.
The screenplay and direction of this film is so muddled and disjointed that, if I hadn't read the book, I don't know if I could have even figured out who the characters were. There is virtually no character development so it's hard to know who the people are or why they are doing what do in the film - or why you should care. The battle scenes are intense but the grey, jerky, surreal filming technique is distracting and annoying.
I'm a huge fan of Clint Eastwood's movies but this time he just fell down flat.
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
Flags of our Fathers
Added 12/8/2009
This product came to me in a timely manner, Thank You for getting this dvd out to me so quickly!
0 out of 1 people found this helpful.
|
EASTWOOD CRACKS A TOUGH NUT!
Added 11/21/2009
Just had a look at a description of the book on which this film was based. Made understandable the structure of the film which somewhat puzzled and a little disturbed me as I saw it. Felt the interweaving of combat with later events weakened the impact of each. However, turns out the book was an extensive study of the lives of 6 men and the combat which united them at the pole on which they placed and raised the American flag on a hill in Iwo Jima. Not having a mini-series of 10 or more hours at their disposal and yet having to, (by contractual arrangement), or wanting to, they had to cover both facets of the book in one two hour movie. They did a fine job. The combat scenes stand up very well, the civilian scenes less so since the personalities formed in the early years prior to service might have explained better the situational accommodations made to post-combat conditions. At any rate, this is a film worth seeing mostly for the thesis that men (and, now, women )in combat are mostly ordinary people who have to adjust to extraordinary circumstances and react often in extraordinary ways. While the brutality of war is suggested, no film can convey the extent to which fear, hatred, the close bonds of the primary group in the military, the shattering of bodies and souls, and sheer necessity create a boiling cauldron out of which anything can emerge.
Certainly, a notable film despite minor flaws.
1 out of 2 people found this helpful.
|
Love the Blu Ray
Added 11/19/2009
This DVD is blu ray and really looks crystal clear on my HDTV! Great interactive menus and docudrama included.
The picture is set in WWII and has that "look" about it. It's NOT your TV, it's the way it was filmed. You know the story, six Marines raise the flag on Mt. Suribachi, in February of 1945. A picture was taken that mesmerised the country and the three marines that weren't killed, in the meantime, were sent on a bond tour that raised more money than ALL previous Bond tours combined! You learn about the men who raised the flags(yes there were TWO flags raised that day. The flag that became famous and which the picture won a Pulitzer prize was hardly even noticed when these Marines changed the first flag out, because a politician wanted that first flag) in a way that was never told before. Great story, well filmed! The actual war scenes are graphic, but the main story is about the men who raised the flag and less on the actual battle.
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
reasonably impressed
Added 9/22/2009
With only a few reservations, I have to say I was reasonably impressed with this Clint Eastwood creation that documents the life stories of the men who raised the American flag at The Battle of Iwo Jima in World War II. I thought they did a convincing job of showing us how facts and reality can be so liquid, how the government and military tries to manipulate the public and, ultimately, how the public so craves certain icons--heroes to hold high on their shoulders, worthy of such status or not--that they're willing to believe whatever they're sold. The war scenes I found brutally effective and gripping, something you just kind of sit there and absorb in a trance, vaguely thankful that the path of your life has never taken you there. I was also struck by the casual, accepted racism towards the Native American Ira Hayes. What a different world it was then, worse in many ways, but so much better in others as well. Using a cast of relative no-name actors also added to the overall effect for me; rarely was I thinking, Oh I remember him from some other movie or TV show. I did feel it dragged on at the end, getting perhaps overly sentimental with certain aspects. But still, I liked it overall. And the photo sequence that ran during the credits that was capped off by a film shot from the memorial on Iwo Jima today was a fitting touch to end on.
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
Huge disappointment!
Added 1/30/2010
I bought this DVD after reading the book and anxiously waited for it to arrive. I guess great anticipation leads to great disappointment because this is one of the worst movies I have seen in a long time. I even watched it again just to be fair thinking maybe I had had a bad night. No, it was even worse the second time.
Let me say that I was incredibly moved by the book. It made the human experience of WWII real to me in a way that no History Channel documentary ever could. I felt I knew the characters and was moved to tears by their stories.
The screenplay and direction of this film is so muddled and disjointed that, if I hadn't read the book, I don't know if I could have even figured out who the characters were. There is virtually no character development so it's hard to know who the people are or why they are doing what do in the film - or why you should care. The battle scenes are intense but the grey, jerky, surreal filming technique is distracting and annoying.
I'm a huge fan of Clint Eastwood's movies but this time he just fell down flat.
0 out of 0 people found this helpful.
|
Flags of our Fathers
Added 12/8/2009
This product came to me in a timely manner, Thank You for getting this dvd out to me so quickly!
0 out of 1 people found this helpful.
|
EASTWOOD CRACKS A TOUGH NUT!
Added 11/21/2009
Just had a look at a description of the book on which this film was based. Made understandable the structure of the film which somewhat puzzled and a little disturbed me as I saw it. Felt the interweaving of combat with later events weakened the impact of each. However, turns out the book was an extensive study of the lives of 6 men and the combat which united them at the pole on which they placed and raised the American flag on a hill in Iwo Jima. Not having a mini-series of 10 or more hours at their disposal and yet having to, (by contractual arrangement), or wanting to, they had to cover both facets of the book in one two hour movie. They did a fine job. The combat scenes stand up very well, the civilian scenes less so since the personalities formed in the early years prior to service might have explained better the situational accommodations made to post-combat conditions. At any rate, this is a film worth seeing mostly for the thesis that men (and, now, women )in combat are mostly ordinary people who have to adjust to extraordinary circumstances and react often in extraordinary ways. While the brutality of war is suggested, no film can convey the extent to which fear, hatred, the close bonds of the primary group in the military, the shattering of bodies and souls, and sheer necessity create a boiling cauldron out of which anything can emerge.
Certainly, a notable film despite minor flaws.
1 out of 2 people found this helpful.
|
